Pizza by Michael

Pizza by Michael, located conveniently at 12 Common St in Saco, ME, is a cherished local spot that masterfully blends the warmth of a family-run business with mouthwatering Italian-American flavors. Specializing in pizza takeaway, ice cream, and sandwiches, this neighborhood gem offers something truly special for every craving, whether you’re looking for a quick slice, a hearty sandwich, or a sweet treat to complete your meal.

What immediately stands out at Pizza by Michael is their dedication to traditional pizza craftsmanship. For over five decades, their philosophy has remained steadfast: fresh dough, flavorful sauce that dances on the palate without overwhelming sweetness, and generous toppings that celebrate bold, balanced flavors. Popular offerings like the Pepperoni Pizza, Greek Pizza, and inventive favorites such as Pickle Pizza and the loaded Pepperoni Hamburger and Onion showcase their imaginative twist on classic pie essentials. Every bite delivers a satisfying crunch from the perfectly baked crust, followed by the savory, savory embrace of toppings that feel both comforting and exciting.

Beyond pizza, their robust appetizer selection—from crispy Mozzarella Sticks and spicy Jalapeno Poppers to homemade Buffalo Chicken Sandwiches—creates a diverse menu that invites repeated visits. Their sandwiches, such as the hearty Chicken Parmesan Sub and savory Steak and Cheese Sub, are constructed with fresh ingredients and a genuine attention to flavor layering that transports you right to an authentic Italian deli experience.

Ice cream lovers also rejoice at the inclusive and friendly service here. According to customer Janeajia Green, the ice cream delights are not only delicious but served with care to accommodate allergies, ensuring everyone can indulge safely. This level of attentiveness is echoed in the broader customer experience—Cassie Fisher’s story of a staff member personally going out to fetch fresh lettuce speaks volumes about the genuine care and pride the team takes in their craft and customer satisfaction.

The dining atmosphere reflects the restaurant’s rich history and community roots. With decor that nods lovingly to its decades-long presence, Pizza by Michael carries the nostalgic charm of a place that’s been a neighbor and a dependable staple for generations. Customer Andy Martin lauds the consistent quality and reasonable pricing that keep him coming back, while “sweet thunder” perfectly sums up the essence with praise for the fresh dough and unpretentious, flavorful sauce that keep the pizza "so tasty" after 56 years in business.

Pizza by Michael is not just a meal—it’s a heartfelt tradition, a taste of genuine generosity and culinary passion. Whether you’re a longtime local or just passing through Saco, it’s a spot that invites you to sit back, savor the lively flavors, and enjoy a slice of community history with every mouthwatering bite.